Blog · Contracts ·
Payor contract renegotiation: what independent practices should know
Many independent practices sign payer contracts once and never look at them again. Over time, rates can fall behind costs and behind what other payers pay. Renegotiation is not guaranteed to work, but it is often worth exploring.
Start by knowing what you have
Before asking for anything, gather your current contracts and fee schedules. For each payer, note: - The contract start date and renewal terms - How rates are set (a fixed fee schedule, a percentage of Medicare or another method) - Timely filing and appeal deadlines - Any notice periods for changes
Find your most important codes
You do not need to review every code. Look at the procedure codes that make up most of your revenue. Small rate changes on those codes matter far more than large changes on codes you rarely bill.
Compare against reference points
A common reference point is the Medicare fee schedule for your area. Comparing each payer's rate for your top codes to Medicare shows which contracts are relatively low. You can also compare payers against each other.
Build your case
Payers respond better to a clear, factual request than to a general complaint. A good request usually includes: - The codes and current rates you want reviewed - How those rates compare to reference points - What your practice offers the payer's members: access, specialty services, quality measures, short wait times or locations - A specific ask
What to expect
Payers decide whether to change rates. Some will respond quickly; others will take months or say no. Large national payers may be less flexible than regional plans. Keep records of every request and response.
Watch the calendar
Contracts often have renewal dates and notice windows. Requests made close to those dates tend to get more attention. Put them on a calendar so you are not surprised.
When to get help
Renegotiation takes time and data. If your team does not have capacity, a billing partner can help gather rate data, prepare the request and track payer responses. The decision to accept new terms always stays with you.